← All posts

Strategy · 20 June 2025

Consultancy, Agency or In-House? A clear guide for Scottish SMEs.

Struggling to choose between a consultant, agency or in-house team? This clear guide helps SMEs compare costs, control and scalability — with real-world scenarios.

By Yann Hamonou

One of the most common questions I hear from Scottish SME owners is: "Should I hire someone in-house, use an agency, or bring in a consultant?"

The honest answer is: it depends on where you are and what you actually need. Here's a clear breakdown.

The Three Options

Marketing Consultant

Best for: Strategic direction, specialist expertise, transformation projects, and situations where you need senior thinking without senior salary costs.

Typical engagement: Project-based (3–6 months) or ongoing advisory retainer (1–2 days/week).

What you get:

  • Direct access to senior-level expertise
  • Objective perspective (no internal politics)
  • Flexible scope — scale up or down as needed
  • Usually faster to engage than hiring

Watch out for:

  • Execution capacity is limited — consultants advise and direct, they don't always build and run
  • Depends heavily on the individual's relevance to your sector and stage

Marketing Agency

Best for: Execution at scale — producing campaigns, content, ads, and creative at volume.

Typical engagement: Monthly retainer (£2,000–£10,000+/month).

What you get:

  • Team capacity across multiple specialisms
  • Established processes and tools
  • Clear deliverables and SLAs

Watch out for:

  • Junior staff often do the day-to-day work after the senior pitch
  • Agencies optimise for their own services, not your optimal channel mix
  • Strategy is often an afterthought — agencies execute, they rarely question the brief

In-House Team

Best for: Businesses with consistent, high-volume marketing needs and the runway to wait 6–9 months for ROI.

Typical cost: £35,000–£55,000/year for a Marketing Manager; much more for a team.

What you get:

  • Deep company knowledge
  • Full alignment with business culture and goals
  • Long-term capability building

Watch out for:

  • Expensive to get wrong
  • One person can't cover all specialisms
  • Risk of "marketing bubble" — no outside perspective

Which One is Right for You?

ScenarioBest fit
Need strategy before you build a teamConsultant
Have a team but no senior guidanceConsultant
Need to run paid media campaignsAgency
Scaling and need content volumeAgency
Revenue to support £50k+ headcountIn-house
Complex product requiring deep expertiseIn-house + consultant

The Combination That Works Best for Most SMEs

For most B2B SMEs in the £1M–£10M revenue range, the highest-leverage combination is:

  1. Consultant for strategy, positioning, and oversight (ongoing advisory)
  2. Specialist agencies or freelancers for execution (paid media, content, web)
  3. One in-house coordinator to manage the above when you're ready to scale

This gives you senior thinking, flexible execution, and control — without the overhead of a full agency retainer or the risk of a premature in-house hire.

The Free Way to Figure It Out

Book a free 30-minute strategy review. I'll look at where you are, what you need, and tell you honestly whether a consultant, agency, or in-house hire is the right next move for your business.

Free B2B marketing insights

Get the playbook

Practical B2B marketing strategy — SEO, positioning, and lead gen — sent direct to your inbox. No fluff, no pitch. Unsubscribe any time.

Want this applied to your business?

Book a free 30-minute strategy review. We'll look at how these ideas apply specifically to your situation.